For once, a video that does justice to the book: The Green Man

You’ve heard the refrain: if only the movie had been true to the book, it would have been so much better! Of course, much of what can make a book good are things that are difficult to capture in a visual medium. And then there’s the problem of one’s own visualization being different from the movie. All of which leads to the conclusion that there is no mechanical way to transfer a book to the screen.

Etching_of_Vendome_Green_Man_misericord

A green man
(Attr: Simon Garbutt)

Partly because his name came up in Brian Aldiss’s Billion Year Spree (and Trillion Year Spree, which I’ve also finished reading), and partly because I’d heard of the story, I recently picked up Kingsley Amis’s 1969 ghost story, The Green Man. Although I enjoyed the story, I didn’t think that much of it at first. However, as I reviewed it in my mind I had to admit it was a nifty bit of work. It reads something like a slapdash ghost story, but it’s actually carefully constructed, with numerous comparisons and contrasts being drawn. Amis also gets his digs in at some of the sillier notions from the late 1960s, while suggesting there may not actually be all that much new under the sun.

A silver ornament that looks similar figures in the story. (Photo: Wikipedia/Richard Croft)

A silver ornament that looks similar figures in the story.
(Photo: Wikipedia/Richard Croft)

So what’s it about? Our protagonist, Maurice Allington, is the keeper of the Green Man, an inn a bit off the beaten path in Hertfordshire. He is, shall we say, a charming cad. He has his difficulties: a family falling apart, a drinking habit that is ruining his health, and a ghost. For the inn is haunted by one Dr. Thomas Underhill, late of Cambridge University. Very late, in fact: Underhill lived in the 17th century. In his own way, he was a charming cad, too. And that is one reason he’s going to be a problem for Maurice Allington.

(By the way, this is definitely a story for adults, in both the book and video versions. There’s a fair bit of nudity and sex, the latter not terribly explicit in either the book or the video adaptation.)

Underhill on the left, Allington on the right

Underhill on the left, Allington (Finney) on the right

The British Broadcasting Company and the American network Arts & Entertainment collaborated on a three part adaptation shown on TV in 1990. It’s a good adaptation. The producers and screenwriters followed the book where they could, and came up with clever ways to cover some material in cinematic fashion. Underhill’s history, for example, instead of being dumped in our laps at the beginning as in the book, is unveiled step-by-step as Maurice has to cope with the ghost. It’s hard to imagine anyone else playing Maurice Allington after you see Albert Finney in the role. He looks like one would imagine Maurice Allington: an older man, once handsome, still with some of his looks, and a bit of weight around the middle, charming without being good.

What makes the story work, both as a book and TV movie, is the dynamic between Maurice Allington and Dr. Thomas Underhill. They are both “bad boys,” as Maurice’s father puts it. And when they come to deal with each other, each will stay true to his character. The results will not be what you expect, unless you’ve been paying very, very close attention. But they are satisfying.

About Brian Bixby

I enjoy history because it helps me understand people. I'm writing fiction for much the same reason.
This entry was posted in Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to For once, a video that does justice to the book: The Green Man

  1. Judy says:

    Curious!! I must take a read!! Nice write up too!! It is always a surprise and a pleasure when you find a movie adaptation actually does justice to a book.

  2. I haven’t heard of this one before, but I try to check it out – I love a good ghost story, especially at this time of year when the chilly nights are drawing in…

  3. Pingback: It’s Time To Fish For Beta Readers (Updated) | The L. Palmer Chronicles

  4. Pingback: What Keeps Me Reading (Blogs) | The L. Palmer Chronicles

  5. Brian Bixby says:

    For anyone following the L. Palmer pingbacks, if you’re looking for educational content, try out the “History” category link for this blog (further up the page in the right-hand column) to dip into the more educational stuff.

  6. crimsonprose says:

    If I’ve enjoyed the book I tend then to stay away from the movie. Hence, I’ve not seen this. I shall now amend my lack. Nice write up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s